Don’t Max Out Your 401k Annually
These days, every time I read a blog or some online article where people simply preach about 401k or are celebrating their annual max out of 401k contribution, I… just chuckle. That’s me being polite.
People, please stop blindly echoing and following each other. Do some studying, learning, thinking for yourself. There are certain things you need to consider, keep reading.
First thing first, if your company provides 50% or 100% of certain amount of contribution, by all means, take advantage of it. Beyond that, perhaps you should re-consider the benefits and the (over)hype of 401k.
Now, pay attention to the points below. For each, take a minute and pause and see if it makes sense. Don’t just take my words for it.
- At the rate our national debt is going, do you think a bet on having low income tax rate in the future is a smart bet? Especially when income tax rate for low to medium income households are very low currently.
- Following previous point, withdrawal from 401k account is taxed at income tax rate, versus, withdrawal from taxable account and only its gain is taxed at capital gain tax rate. If government must raise taxes, which is likely to be increased more? Which is likely to be lower in the future? The answer is capital gain tax rate.
“But 401k grows with pre-tax money, blah blah blah…” Yes I know. But if I am to make a conservative plan, which is what we should do for something so far down the road. I will bet on the latter because there is less variables, meaning, I know the taxed principal will be there (I should have a good percetage back to “cash” near “old age”). Better to overestimate than underestimate.
- Depends on the 401k account management, the chance for shady, kick-back, and “hidden” fees is not negligible.
- Many 401k accounts do not provide “good” selection of funds.
- Generically speaking, if you need you money to be locked up in order to save, there is a bigger situation about yourself that you need to handle. Namely, responsibility, discipline, foresight…
- The population is aging. More people are retiring than people joining the workforce. That means likelihood of more people selling (whatever that’s left in the account) stocks and bonds in the 401k than people buying in. This puts pressure against future stock growth. I guess we have to be cautious with our belief in future growth in general.
- Lastly, we don’t live forever and can very well die before 60s. I am not sure about locking up all that money, that I cannot access and use without penalty except for some very dire siutations. There can be good argument against this, but I still think there is value in this thought. Mainly, we are not immortal. Stop living like we are.
So now you have my skepticism with 401k. Again, if there is matching from your company, get it. That’s “free” money. Otherwise, it would be a good idea to spread things out some in taxable accounts than having full belief and your $$$ in the 401k basket. It’s not that difficult… just following the same allocation in both places. You do have some ideas of your portfolio allocation, right?
Meanwhile, I contribute to my company’s matching. Maxing out my 401k yearly? I’ll pass. (I don’t do Roth IRA either…)
Update: Thanks Meg for pointing out my confusing comments with Roth IRA which is corrected. It is my own decision not to. If interested why I don’t, read comment.
I’m thinking about upgrading my computer, as the (un)fortunate nature of being a geek who is into gadget. With my computer science and system administrator background plus personal research, I share some tips and guides if you are in the market of buying a computer.
The truth is, my current laptop, XPS M1210 — 2GHz Core 2 CPU, 2GB RAM, 7200RPM 250GB Harddrive — is still a mid-range laptop even now, which I bought 2.5+ years ago off Craiglist. I am in no hurry to upgrade. Oh, my trusty XPS M1210… so I tell myself :P
The noise of the day fades away.
Recent Comments